Back to all guides

BuildMyEvidence · guide

When they say you didn't do it

You paid it, sent it, turned up, told them, finished the job. They say you did not. Here is what actually settles that kind of disagreement.

Last updated Oct 10, 2026

Dave Shelton, founder of BuildMyEvidence.

Written by Dave Shelton, founder of BuildMyEvidence. Thirty years in business taught him that the person with a clear record gets taken seriously.

This is the most winnable kind of dispute

Whether you did something is, unlike most things people argue about, a question with a factual answer that leaves traces.

Money moves and a bank records it. Email arrives and a server logs it. A parcel is scanned. A phone connects to a call. A door opens with a fob. Almost nothing happens without something, somewhere, writing it down.

Which means your job is narrow: find the trace, and present it so a stranger can check it in under a minute.

Find the trace

Depending on what they say you did not do:

  • Paid it. The bank or card statement line, with the date and the payee. Better than a receipt, because you cannot edit a statement. Also: the transfer confirmation, the payment reference, the auto-pay setup.
  • Sent it. The item in your sent folder, with its date and time. The read receipt if you have one. The certified mail or courier tracking. A reply that quotes what you sent, which proves arrival better than your own copy does.
  • Turned up. The calendar entry, the parking receipt, the fuel purchase, the card used nearby, the visitor log, the fob record, the photograph with its date, somebody else who was there.
  • Told them. The message, the email, the note of the call written the same day, or the next thing you did that only makes sense if you had told them.
  • Finished the work. The dated photographs, the sign-off, the invoice they paid, the materials receipts, the follow-up message where they said thanks.

Make it checkable in one minute

Having the evidence is half the job. The other half is presenting it so nobody has to work.

  • Point at the exact line. Not a 40-page statement — the statement page with the transaction, with the date, amount and payee visible.
  • Say what it shows, in one sentence. "Item 4: bank statement, Mar 3, payment to Harrow Plumbing."
  • Put it in date order and number it.
  • Give the whole document, not a crop. A cropped statement line invites the thought that something nearby was removed.

When the trace is thin

Sometimes it is. You paid in cash, the conversation was in a corridor, the work was done without paperwork.

Then say so straight, and build what you can around it: the withdrawal from the machine an hour before, the message afterwards referring to it, the person who saw it, your own note from the day.

A claim that is honest about what it can and cannot show is treated very differently from one that overstates. And "I paid in cash, here is the withdrawal and here is the message where they acknowledged it" is a real answer.

What makes a record believable

Get the records you do not hold

Some of this is held by somebody else and most of it can be asked for.

Banks produce statements going back years. Phone companies produce call records. Couriers hold tracking. Employers hold entry logs. Platforms hold order histories. Ask early, in writing, and keep the asking — a request that was ignored is itself worth recording.

The letter for this

“Answer ‘you didn’t do it’” lists the dated items for each point. What you conclude from them is yours to write.

Related

Frequently asked questions

I know I sent it but I can't find it.

Search your sent folder for the recipient's name rather than the subject, and check the archive, spam and any second account. If it was sent from a work or platform account you no longer have, ask for it in writing before the window closes.

They say they never received it.

Those are two different claims — that you did not send it, and that it did not arrive. Your sent copy answers the first. A reply, a read receipt or tracking answers the second. Be clear about which one you can show.

It was all verbal.

Then write down now what you remember, with today's date on it, and look for the things around it: the message that followed, the work that started, the money that moved.

This guide is general information and is not legal advice. Laws vary by location. For advice about your situation, consult a qualified lawyer. How we write these