BuildMyEvidence · guide
The record you already have
Before you gather anything, go and look at what is already sitting on your phone and in your inbox. Most people in a dispute think they have nothing. They are nearly always wrong.
Last updated Oct 10, 2026
Written by Dave Shelton, founder of BuildMyEvidence. Thirty years in business taught him that the person with a clear record gets taken seriously.
You are not starting from zero
The belief that you have no evidence is the single most common thing that stops somebody answering properly. It is also almost never true.
You have been carrying a recording device for years. It has been dating everything you do without being asked. So has your bank, your email provider, your phone company and whoever sold you anything.
The work in front of you is not creating a record. It is finding the one you made without meaning to.
Where to look, in order
Spend an hour on this before you write a word.
- Your messages. The whole thread, not the part that helps. Texts, WhatsApp, Messenger, the app you booked through. Dates are attached to every one of them.
- Your email. Search the other side's name, the company name and the address of the property or job. Then search your own sent folder, which people forget — what you said at the time is often more useful than what they said.
- Your photographs. Not just the ones you took of the problem. Birthdays, Christmas, moving day, the dog. The condition of a room, a car, a wall or a piece of equipment is in the background of an ordinary photograph, on a date nobody can argue with.
- Your bank and card statements. They date every payment and name who got it. For anything about money, they are better than a receipt because they cannot be edited.
- Your calendar. Appointments, visits, who came, when.
- Your call log. It will not tell you what was said, but it will tell you that a six-minute call happened on the 14th, which is sometimes the whole point.
- Voicemail. People leave remarkable things on voicemail. Save them off the phone.
- Anything with a tracking number. Delivery, courier, certified mail, a repair docket.
- What other people hold. The contractor's invoice, the clinic's notes, the agent's inspection report, a receipt in a friend's inbox because they paid. You can ask for these.
Save it today, somewhere that is not the phone
Phones get lost, wiped, upgraded and run out of space. Accounts get closed. Workplace email gets switched off the day a dispute becomes official.
So today: back it up. Email the key things to yourself, copy the photographs to a computer or a drive, download the statements as files rather than relying on being able to log in later.
If any of it sits on a system that somebody else controls — a work account, a platform you are in dispute with, a shared family account — get your copy out now rather than later.
Keep the original, not a picture of it
This matters more than people expect.
Keep the actual email, not a screenshot of it. The photograph from the camera roll, not a photograph of the screen. The PDF as it was sent, not your retyped version of the figures.
Originals carry their own dates and details inside them. A screenshot of a screenshot carries nothing, and a reader who notices that is a reader who starts discounting the rest.
Find the date a photo or video was takenThen write down what is missing
When you have swept all of that, you will have two lists: what you hold, and the gaps.
The gaps are useful. They tell you what to start recording from today, and they tell you what to ask somebody else for while you still can. A gap you have named and explained is a reasonable thing. A gap nobody mentions looks like something being left out.
Putting it in order after the factRelated
Frequently asked questions
Is a screenshot good enough?
It is better than nothing and far weaker than the original. Keep both where you can, and say which is which.
They deleted their messages. Mine still show the thread.
Then yours are the record. Keep the whole thread, including your own messages you would rather not include.
Can I use a recording I made?
Recording rules differ from state to state and getting it wrong creates a bigger problem than the one you have. A written note made straight after a call needs nobody's permission.
This guide is general information and is not legal advice. Laws vary by location. For advice about your situation, consult a qualified lawyer. How we write these