Back to all guides

BuildMyEvidence · guide

When they ask you for documents

A request has arrived — from an employer, an insurer, an agency, a lawyer, a board. Sending everything is a mistake. So is sending nothing. Here is how to work out what is actually being asked for and how to send it.

Last updated Oct 10, 2026

Dave Shelton, founder of BuildMyEvidence.

Written by Dave Shelton, founder of BuildMyEvidence. Thirty years in business taught him that the person with a clear record gets taken seriously.

Read what was actually requested

Requests are often broader than the person writing them intended, and they are frequently copied from a template.

Go through it and write out, separately, each distinct thing being asked for. Then for each one: do you have it, is it clear what it covers, and does it have a date range.

A request that says "all correspondence" is not usually a request for seven years of email. Asking "do you mean correspondence about X, between these dates?" is a normal and sensible question, and it goes in writing.

Send what was asked for, not everything

There is a strong instinct, especially when you have done nothing wrong, to send everything and let them see you have nothing to hide.

Don't. Three reasons, and the third is the one that catches people.

  1. It buries the thing that helps you.
  2. It hands over things that were never asked about and may raise questions of their own.
  3. It takes away your ability to say later what you did and did not provide, because nobody — including you — knows what was in a folder of four hundred files.

Send what was asked for. Say in the cover message what you have sent and what you have not, and why.

Before you send, three checks

  • Is it complete within itself? A message thread with the middle removed looks worse than a thread with something unhelpful in it. Send whole documents.
  • Have you kept a copy of exactly what you sent? Not approximately. The actual files, with the date you sent them, saved separately. If this goes on, which version you provided and when will matter.
  • Is anything in here somebody else's private information? Other people's medical details, a third party's bank details, somebody's home address, a photograph of a child. Those often need to be removed before sending, and quietly removing them is different from quietly removing something inconvenient — say that you have done it and why.

If you cannot provide something

Say so clearly, say why, and say what you do have instead.

"I don't have the original invoice. I have the bank statement line showing the payment, attached as item 6." That is an answer. Silence on one item in a list of eight looks like avoidance even when it is just forgetfulness.

If you never had it, say that too. People assume a gap means a document was withheld.

Never alter a document

The single rule that has no exceptions anywhere on this site.

Do not tidy it, do not add the note you meant to write at the time, do not correct a date to what you know it should have been, do not re-export a file with today's date to make it look neater.

If something needs explaining, explain it in your cover note. An inaccurate document with an explanation attached is a normal thing. An altered document is the end of your credibility and, depending on the setting, a great deal worse.

The cover note

Short. Four lines.

"Attached are the documents requested in your letter of the 14th. Items 1 to 6 cover points 1, 2 and 4 of your request. I do not hold anything responsive to point 3. For point 5 I have the bank record rather than the invoice, attached as item 6. Happy to provide anything further."

That note is also your own record of what you sent, which is why it is worth writing properly.

Handing over your record

The letter for this

“Send what was asked for” lists each item from your record. When you send it, it goes back into the record with its date, so the list of what went is kept for you.

Related

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to send what they've asked for?

That depends entirely on who is asking and under what authority, and it is not something this page can answer. The request itself, your contract or policy, and — where the amount at stake is significant — your own advice are where that comes from.

Can I ask for more time?

Usually, and asking in writing before the date passes is far better than being late. Keep the copy.

They're asking for things that have nothing to do with it.

Ask, in writing, how those relate to the matter. That question is reasonable, it is on the record, and it often narrows the request without anybody taking offense.

This guide is general information and is not legal advice. Laws vary by location. For advice about your situation, consult a qualified lawyer. How we write these